"Don't Worry, Be Happy": A Psychiatrist Explains When Positivity is Toxic

This blog post was reviewed and approved for publication by Abena Apraku M.D., a Board-certified psychiatrist at Apraku Psychiatry.

​Are you tired of being told not to worry when you’re feeling down? That you should look on the bright side, and that things aren’t as bad as they seem? While these clichéd consolations may be said with good intentions, they can often be counterproductive. Welcome to the hidden world of toxic positivity, where good vibes take a dark turn.

In this eye-opening article, we'll get to grips with toxic positivity and its effects on mental health. Join us as we navigate the fine line between healthy optimism and emotional invalidation, and discover how to foster genuine positivity that respects and supports emotional well-being.

Here's A Little Blog I Wrote

To set the stage, why not start with a sing-along to Bobby McFerrin’s catchy tune, "Don’t Worry, Be Happy"? Whether you find the song lyrics to be positively uplifting or indicative of toxic positivity, you’ve got to admit that McFerrin’s tuneful whistling is a groovy prelude to our discussion!

Here's a little song I wrote
You might want to sing it note for note
Don't worry, be happy
In every life we have some trouble
But when you worry, you make it double
Don't worry, be happy
Don't worry, be happy now

​So, ready to embark on this enlightening journey? Press play to uncover the truth about toxic positivity, and how to strike the right balance in our approach to emotional well-being.

What is Toxic Positivity?

We've all come across the power of positivity, right? The idea that maintaining a positive outlook can help us overcome life's obstacles, and even transform our lives for the better. While there's no denying that positivity plays a crucial role in promoting mental well-being, there is a darker side to it that often goes unnoticed: toxic positivity.

Toxic Positivity: An Overzealous Cousin

Toxic positivity is like the overzealous cousin of genuine positivity. It's an insistence that one must always maintain a positive attitude, regardless of the situation. This mindset rejects the idea that it's okay to feel sad, angry, or anxious and pushes for a constant state of (superficial) happiness. It's the "good vibes only" mantra taken to a pernicious extreme.

Recognizing Toxic Positivity

So, how can you tell if you're dealing with toxic positivity? It often comes in the form of seemingly harmless phrases - such as our lyrical favorite, “don’t worry, be happy”. While such statements might be well-intentioned, they risk dismissing a person's legitimate feelings, coercing them to put on a happy face even when they're struggling.

Imagine you've had a rough day at work, and you share your frustration with a friend. Instead of offering a listening ear or empathizing with your situation, they respond: "Just be happy that you have a job!" In that moment, your feelings are invalidated, and you might even feel guilty for being upset in the first place.

Common Phrases Associated with Toxic Positivity

Other oft-heard phrases that could be interpreted as “toxically positive” include:

• "Everything happens for a reason."
• "Good vibes only."
• "Happiness is a choice."
• "There are people with bigger problems."
• "You'll get over it."
• "Just smile and it'll all be better."
• "It could be worse."

Genuine Positivity: A Balance

At this point, you might be wondering: "Is positivity bad, then?" Not at all! Positivity is incredibly valuable, as long as it's genuine and respectful of a person's emotional experience. The key is to strike a balance between being optimistic and validating the reality of our emotions, including negative ones.

It's therefore important to recognize that toxic positivity is not the same as genuine positivity. Authentic positivity allows for the full range of human emotions and acknowledges that sometimes, it's okay not to be okay. Rather than dismissing negative emotions, genuine positivity encourages self-compassion, resilience, and growth. It promotes a healthy balance between acknowledging challenges and finding hope, even in the face of adversity.

So, the next time you find yourself faced with a friend's struggle or your own emotional turmoil, take a moment to consider whether your positivity is helping or hindering the situation. Remember that it's okay to feel a full spectrum of emotions, and that supporting one another through difficult times often requires more than just a sunny disposition.

Top Highlights

• Toxic positivity is the insistence that one must always maintain a positive attitude, regardless of the situation, and it can have harmful effects on mental health.
• Common phrases associated with toxic positivity include "everything happens for a reason," "good vibes only," and "just be happy."
• To recognize toxic positivity, watch for signs like dismissing or minimizing negative emotions, feeling guilty for experiencing negative emotions, and suppressing or hiding emotions.
• To cultivate a more balanced and supportive mindset, practice self-awareness, promote self-care, foster open communication, offer active listening, use mindful language, offer practical support, and seek professional help if needed.

The Harmful Effects of Toxic Positivity

Now that we've defined toxic positivity and distinguished it from genuine positivity, it's essential to delve into the potential harm it can cause, particularly when it comes to mental health. By understanding the consequences of toxic positivity, we can be better equipped to support ourselves and others during difficult times, without falling into the trap of emotional invalidation.

Invalidating Emotions

One of the primary ways toxic positivity affects mental health is by invalidating emotions. When we're told to "just think positive" or "focus on the good", our negative emotions are implicitly seen as invalid, or even wrong. This can lead to feelings of guilt, shame, and self-blame, which can exacerbate existing mental health issues like depression, anxiety, or trauma.

Encouraging Emotional Suppression

By invalidating emotions, toxic positivity also encourages emotional suppression. When we're constantly pressured to maintain a happy facade, we might start to hide or deny our true feelings. This can have a snowball effect, as suppressing emotions can diminish our sense of well-being and self-worth. Emotional suppression can even exacerbate mental health disorders.

Impairing Coping Mechanisms

Toxic positivity can also hinder our ability to cope with life's challenges. When we're unable to acknowledge and process our negative emotions, we miss out on the opportunity to develop healthy coping mechanisms. Instead, we might resort to unhealthy behaviors such as substance abuse, overeating, or social withdrawal, which can further exacerbate mental health concerns.

Straining Interpersonal Relationships

In addition, toxic positivity can strain interpersonal relationships. When we're not allowed to express our true feelings, it can create a sense of isolation and hinder our ability to connect with others on a deeper level. This lack of connection can be particularly damaging for individuals who are already struggling with mental health issues, as social support is a critical component of recovery and well-being.

Now that we've explored the harmful effects of toxic positivity on mental health, it's important to recognize and address this mindset in ourselves and others. In the upcoming sections, we'll discuss how to identify signs of toxic positivity and provide strategies for fostering a healthy, positive mindset that respects and validates the full range of human emotions.

How to Recognize Toxic Positivity

As we've established, toxic positivity can have detrimental effects on mental health. To address this issue and cultivate healthier mindsets, we must first learn to recognize toxic positivity in ourselves and others. In this section, we'll explore some of the tell-tale signs of toxic positivity:

• Dismissing or minimizing negative emotions: One of the most common indicators of toxic positivity is a tendency to brush off or downplay negative feelings. Saying things like "it's not that bad" could be indicative of toxic positivity.
• Feeling guilty for experiencing negative emotions: If you often feel guilty or ashamed for having negative emotions, this could be a sign that you're internalizing toxic positivity. Remember that emotions are valid in themselves, and it's normal to experience a range of feelings in response to life's challenges.
• Suppressing or hiding emotions: If you often feel the need to put on a happy face, even when you're struggling, this could also indicate internalized toxic positivity. Pay attention to your own emotional needs and allow yourself the space to express and process your feelings.
• Avoiding difficult conversations or emotions: If you find yourself consistently steering conversations away from negative topics or avoiding discussions about difficult emotions, you might be practicing toxic positivity. In the same vein, if someone you know always changes the subject when you bring up a challenging issue, they could be exhibiting toxic positivity.
• Offering unsolicited advice or platitudes: If you frequently offer advice or clichéd phrases such as "Look on the bright side" without truly listening to or empathizing with the person's situation, you might be engaging in toxic positivity. Be mindful of your responses to others' struggles and try to offer empathy and understanding instead.

It's important to recognize that there are better ways to manage mental health without eating from the "poisoned apple" of toxic positivity. In the next section, we'll delve into some strategies for cultivating a more balanced and supportive mindset that honors the full range of human emotions.

Mental Health Beyond Toxic Positivity

Addressing the issue of toxic positivity requires an understanding that it's not about replacing negative emotions with positive ones. Rather, it's about fostering an environment that respects and supports the full range of human emotions. Here are some strategies to help manage toxic positivity and promote mental health in a more balanced, compassionate way:

• Self-Awareness: Pay attention to your emotional landscape and reactions to negative emotions. Recognize when you're internalizing toxic positivity and practice self-compassion.
• Promote Self-Care: Encourage self-care activities such as exercise, meditation, journaling, or seeking therapy. These practices can promote resilience and emotional balance.
• Open Communication: Foster an environment where it's safe to discuss all emotions, positive or negative. This can create a more supportive and empathetic atmosphere.
• Active Listening: When someone shares their struggles, provide a safe space for them to express themselves. Validate their emotions and try to understand their perspective.
• Mindful Language: Use expressions that validate and support, rather than perpetuate toxic positivity. For example, instead of saying "Just think positive," try saying: "I understand you're going through a tough time, and I'm here for you."
• Offer Practical Support: When someone is struggling, tangible assistance can be invaluable. This can range from helping with daily tasks, providing resources, or simply being there for them.
• Seek Professional Help: If toxic positivity is exacerbating mental health concerns, don't hesitate to seek professional help. A psychiatrist can guide towards healthier coping strategies and emotional regulation techniques.

By practicing these strategies, we can learn to cultivate a more balanced and supportive mindset that honors the full range of human emotions. Rather than denying or suppressing our negative emotions, we can acknowledge and process them in a healthy way, leading to improved mental health and overall well-being.

Conclusion: From Toxic to Enlightened Positivity

Fostering a supportive and empathetic environment is crucial for promoting mental well-being and addressing mental health concerns. By understanding the difference between toxic positivity and enlightened positivity, we can better validate and respect the full range of human emotions, both in ourselves and others. It's essential to recognize that while positivity can be a powerful force, it must be used with care and consideration to avoid inadvertently causing harm.

If you or someone you know is struggling with feelings of invalidation due to toxic positivity, it's important to seek help from a mental health professional, such as a psychiatrist. These professionals can provide guidance on navigating emotional responses and developing healthier coping strategies, even in the face of invalidating environments. Psychiatrists can help individuals recognize and address the impact of toxic positivity on their mental health, offering tailored support to foster emotional resilience and well-being.

By actively listening, empathizing, and validating one another's emotions, we can counteract the damaging effects of toxic positivity and create a more nurturing and understanding space for all. It's essential to prioritize emotional health, engage in self-care, and educate ourselves about mental health issues to support those dealing with mental health concerns effectively. Together, we can cultivate a more balanced and compassionate approach to positivity, one that promotes healing, growth, and connection for everyone.

---

This blog post is brought to you by Apraku Psychiatry.

Apraku Psychiatry is a private practice offering video appointments with Board-certified psychiatrists licensed in multiple states. More blog articles can be found here. To schedule an appointment with one of our psychiatrists, patients can complete the online booking form.